The identity-frame model: A framework to describe situated identity negotiation for adolescent youth participating in an informal engineering education program

June 16th, 2020 | RESEARCH

Background. STEM identity has emerged as an important research topic and a predictor of how youth engage with STEM inside and outside of school. Although there is a growing body of literature in this area, less work has been done specific to engineering, especially in out-of-school learning contexts.

Methods. To address this need, we conducted a qualitative investigation of five adolescent youth participating in a four-month afterschool engineering program. The study focused on how participants negotiated engineering-related identities through ongoing interactions with activities, peers, and adults, and the patterns of identity negotiation that emerged across program sessions.

Findings. Through the investigation, we developed an Identity-Frame Model, positing that identity negotiation is an ongoing process of performance and definition work by an individual and recognition and positioning work by other adults and peers that creates emergent, context-specific identities and activity frames that are made particularly salient during critical identity moments. We also categorized model elements that appeared to be specific to engineering, such as situated identities and activity frames related to failure, collaboration, and competition.

Contribution. The study advances the understanding of identity negotiation related to engineering and provides a new framework for investigating situated identity in informal STEM learning contexts.



Team Members

Scott Pattison, Author, TERC
Ivel Gontan, Author, Fleet Science Center
Smirla Ramos-Montañez, Author, TERC
Todd Shagott, Author, Oregon Museum of Science and Industry
Melanie Francisco, Author, Oregon Museum of Science and Industry
Lynn Dierking, Author, Oregon State University


Identifier Type: doi
Identifier: 10.1080/10508406.2020.1770762

Publication: Journal of the Learning Sciences


Funding Source: NSF
Funding Program: ISE/AISL
Award Number: 1322306

Related URLs

Designing Our World: A Community Envisioning Girls as Engineers


Access and Inclusion: English Language Learners | Ethnic | Racial | Hispanic | Latinx Communities | Low Socioeconomic Status | Women and Girls
Audience: Adults | Educators | Teachers | Elementary School Children (6-10) | Evaluators | Learning Researchers | Middle School Children (11-13) | Museum | ISE Professionals
Discipline: Education and learning science | Engineering
Resource Type: Peer-reviewed article | Research Products
Environment Type: Afterschool Programs | Public Programs